Rock Concert Review: Billy Joel — A Seamless Show

By Paul Robicheau

Billy Joel remains in fine voice and his versatile bandmates provided his songs with grace and fire power that fleshed out his casual but punchy onstage prowess.

Billy Joel on piano at Fenway Park. Photo: Paul Robicheau.

Billy Joel blames the fans. “Who would have told me I’d be doing this job at 70 years old,” the piano man told his annual full house of the faithful while closing Fenway Park’s 2019 concert season on Saturday. “And you’re still coming to see me, so it’s your fault. I can’t retire — until you stop buying these fucking tickets!”

There’s a good reason why people don’t stop, however, when Joel and his crack eight-piece band keep rocking seamless shows like his sixth consecutive one-night stand at Boston’s ballpark. A banner unfurled on the Green Monster declared the Long Island legend to be the first performer in the Fenway Music Hall of Fame.

Joel — who hasn’t released an album since 1993 — boasted that he didn’t have anything new, just the “same old shit,” and poked fun at other bands that play new songs only to send fans to the bathroom. But if his selection of songs hasn’t changed much from year to year, Joel changed up the order across a two-hour-plus set and injected a few rarities.

Billy Joel on guitar at Fenway Park. Photo: Paul Robicheau.

He balanced the cinematic crescendos and saloon piano spools of “The Ballad of Billy the Kid” after imitating a clomping horse with his mouth clicks in a winsome intro, then joked that would be the difficult song that he’d mess up to force his retirement. He served up the jazzy showpiece “Big Man on Mulberry Street” and went most far afield with the minor 1980 glide “Sleeping with the Television On,” which rode catch-phrase band harmonies of “All night long” and “Talk to me.”

Joel remains in fine voice and his versatile bandmates provided his songs with grace and fire power that fleshed out his casual but punchy onstage prowess. Saxophonist Mark Rivera topped “New York State of Mind” with elegant tenor and was joined by usual trumpeter Carl Fischer and percussion dynamo Crystal Taliefero in a melodious three-way sax section during “Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song),” the song whose “Heart attack, ack, ack, ack, ack, ack” hook birthed a moniker for a local Joel tribute band. Mike Delguidice and Tommy Byrne’s beefy twin guitars fueled tunes like “Big Shot.” And Delguidice wowed with his traditional opera vocal on “Nessun Dorma,” a different kind of cover than Saturday takes on Boston’s “More Than a Feeling” (not the first time that one’s popped up at Fenway), “A Hard Day’s Night” and “I Feel Fine,” a double shot to satiate Joel’s obvious love for the Beatles.

Joel’s own tunes are sometimes derided as saccharine songcraft, and he did push crowd-pleasing buttons at mid-set with “Don’t Ask Me Why” and “She’s Always a Woman,” but that sells short his broader character studies. He brought the crowd to sea for fisherman’s plight “The Downeaster Alexa” and to the slide of a blue-collar town in “Allentown.” And the set naturally wound down with “Scenes from an Italian Restaurant,” a tour-de-force around the saga of Brenda and Eddie, and the immortal “Piano Man,” about an observant barroom balladeer that he ended by playfully dashing his harmonica to the stage. You couldn’t blame the crowd for enjoying a boisterous sing-along to the line “We’re all in the mood for a melody, and you’ve got us feeling all right.”

Joel was chatty as usual, noting songs that were “more bombs than hits” (like it made much difference to his fans today) and playing to the hometown baseball team as a New Yorker who thought Ted Williams was “the greatest hitter I’ve seen in my life.”

And as he played guitar on his rat-a-tat history list “We Didn’t Start the Fire,” twirled a mic stand to “Uptown Girl,” and rocked his piano stool like a bucking bronco on “You May Be Right” (before a searing tag of Led Zeppelin’s “Rock ‘n’ Roll”), it was clear that Joel’s more than ready to keep serenading into his 70s.

Paul Robicheau served as the contributing editor for music in The Improper Bostonian in addition to writing and photography for The Boston Globe, Rolling Stone and other publications.


  1. Alan on August 15, 2021 at 8:53 pm

    I just saw Billy Joel for the first time at Fenway in Aug 2021, a couple weeks ago. I thought him and his band were just absolutely fantastic. Of course your review is pretty accurate even for this year. But upon reflection, he could feel 2 hours of hits, and play five nights in a row and never repeat a song. I mean let’s be honest he has so much material it’s just crazy. They might not have all been in the top 10 but there’s plenty of albums that are full of songs that we would all love to hear. And the fact that he’s still cranking it out so well, at 72 is just amazing. His songwriting is not “saccarine” but it’s usually raw, honest and highly personal. His break with Christie Brinkley might have crushed his creativity eventually, but that relationship, from start to finish with every bump and doubt in between produced some of the best, introspective, and emotionally raw songwriting ever. I’m not the Entertainer, I’m not the Piano Man, but when Billy Joel sings about relationships, singing about my life, and I can’t stop singing along with him.
    That’s his magic

    • George on August 20, 2021 at 12:50 pm

      Yes to all of this, except it wasn’t his creativity that was crushed, it was his desire to be competitive or relevant in contemporary music. He still writes piano pieces, we just don’t hear most of them. “Fantasies and Delusions” (2001) is the one exception, and it’s worth checking out.

Leave a Comment

Recent Posts