Classical Album Review: Ralph van Raat and Friends Take John Adams’s Chamber Music for a Spin

By Jonathan Blumhofer

Spirited performances of “Roll Over Beethoven” and “Road Movies” anchor a rewarding album of smaller-scale works by a composer best known for thinking big.

John Adams isn’t a composer one automatically associates with chamber music. Rather, the opposite: since the 2000 premiere of El Niño, the Berkeley-based musician has written five operas, two symphonies (by name), and assorted other orchestral works. But in that same time, he’s also crafted a body of music for smaller ensembles, some of which is showcased on a new album anchored by pianist Ralph van Raat.

The most substantial of those works is Roll Over Beethoven, Preben Antonsen’s two-piano arrangement of Adams’s Second String Quartet. Written in 2014, the quartet reflects the composer’s obsession with reworking fragments of late Beethoven into his own vocabulary—in this instance, phrases, cadential patterns, and similar short materials from the Op. 110 piano sonata and Diabelli Variations.

If nothing else, the 20-minute-long result represents a singular approach to these canonic items. Adams’s treatment of them is, broadly speaking, energetic and good-natured—his own style is no stranger to motivic development—and hearing familiar fragments in such unexpected contexts has a way of opening them up. One comes to appreciate that Beethoven’s method with them was just that: his own.

This performance, in which van Raat is joined by Maarten van Veen, veers confidently between the music’s extremes of dynamics, texture, and articulation. There’s an edge to the first movement’s riffs that suggests something of the spirit of Chuck Berry, if not exactly his tone, and the pair navigate the finale’s variation-like shifts with a strong sense of just where the music needs to be heading.

A similar assurance marks the duo’s rendition of Short Ride in a Fast Machine, whose rhythmic intensity comes across with exuberant clarity.

The album’s other big number is Road Movies, Adams’s 1995 duo for violin and piano. Here, again, the composer’s manner with motives is clearly in evidence: there’s an impressive thematic concision at work in all three of its movements.

Van Raat and violinist Rosanne Philippens draw out that aspect of the score with aplomb. The outer movements of Road Movies are dry, precise, and motoric, while the slow middle one, with its scordatura tuning of the fiddle, comes across as appropriately smoky. While lacking some of the explosive dynamic and gestural range of Leila Josefowicz and Nicolas Hodges’s rendition (or Augustin Hadelich and Orion Weiss’s, for that matter), theirs is a roundly satisfying account of this quirky selection.

Filling out the recording are excerpts from two of Adams’s stage works and the keyboard miniature I Still Play. The last—lovely, reflective, and clean-textured—is a surprising little charmer, while the vocal numbers (heard in arrangements by Chitose Okashiro and John McGinn, respectively) do something to bridge the program’s chronological span.

“Am I in Your Light?,” Kitty Oppenheimer’s aria from Doctor Atomic, offers a fair representation of Adams’s mature approach to opera, though two items from I Was Looking at the Ceiling and Then I Saw the Sky—“Consuelo’s Dream” and “Leila’s Song: Alone”—still don’t quite effectively thread the needle between popular and concert worlds (that’s not the fault of McGinn’s adaptations: Ceiling/Sky has long been one of Adams’s most problematic works). Nevertheless, soprano Laura Bohn delivers all three with tonal warmth and excellent diction.


Jonathan Blumhofer is a composer, violist, teacher, and music writer who has been active in the greater Boston area since 2004. In addition to the Fuse, his work has appeared in the Boston Classical Review, Worcester Telegram & Gazette, Notes, and other publications.

Leave a Comment





Recent Posts

Popular Posts

Categories

Archives